Journal of Academy of Medical Sciences

ORIGINAL ARTICLE
Year
: 2012  |  Volume : 2  |  Issue : 2  |  Page : 68--72

Awareness of the revised national tuberculosis control programme and attitude to tuberculosis patients amongst medical undergraduates


Swati M Baveja, Pratibha J Dalal 
 Department of Microbiology, Terna Medical College, Navi Mumbai, Maharashtra, India

Correspondence Address:
Swati M Baveja
212, Type 4, C.G.S. Colony, Wadala (West), Mumbai - 400 031, Maharashtra
India

Abstract

Purpose: This study was conducted to assess the knowledge of Revised National Tuberculosis Control Programme ( RNTCP) and attitude to tuberculosis (TB) among medical students and interns. Materials and Methods: This cross-sectional survey was carried out in a private medical college among 200 medical students. The students were asked to complete a written questionnaire. The answers were statistically analyzed using Statistical Package for the Social Sciences (SPSS) software program, IBM. In addition, item analysis was carried out for each question, wherever applicable. Results: Our analysis revealed that all students were aware of TB. They were also aware of RNTCP. In addition to the didactic lectures, students had gained information from different sources such as textbooks (168), case discussion (155), seminar (95), journals (75), and WHO publications (22). The average number of students with correct response was 122 (59.63%). Among the various categories of TB, the correct responses were highest for questions relating to diagnosis (146.25; 73.12%), followed by epidemiology (114; 62.16%), management (130.33; 61.75%), and risk perception (75.33; 28.5%). About 90% students feared the risk of transmission by inhalation from a TB patient with cough. Majority of the students were aware that all smear-positive patients should be isolated and treated. Item analysis of the multiple choice questions (MCQs) showed the areas that required more emphasis. Conclusions: Overall performance of III/I students was better than the rest of the study group. Students performed better in the epidemiology domain compared with the management and preventive aspects of TB. To ensure the successful control of TB and implementation of RNTCP, medical students need to be sensitized by conducting continuous medical education and orientation courses on RNTCP at regular intervals.



How to cite this article:
Baveja SM, Dalal PJ. Awareness of the revised national tuberculosis control programme and attitude to tuberculosis patients amongst medical undergraduates.J Acad Med Sci 2012;2:68-72


How to cite this URL:
Baveja SM, Dalal PJ. Awareness of the revised national tuberculosis control programme and attitude to tuberculosis patients amongst medical undergraduates. J Acad Med Sci [serial online] 2012 [cited 2019 Sep 18 ];2:68-72
Available from: http://www.e-jams.org/text.asp?2012/2/2/68/118663


Full Text

 Introduction



Tuberculosis (TB) is a serious public health problem in India causing immense morbidity, mortality and distress to individuals, families and communities. TB kills more adults in India than any other infectious disease. The disease incidence peaks in people belonging to the most economically productive age group of 15-60 years. Every day, more than 5000 Indians develop TB and more than 1000 die of TB (two deaths every 3 min). [1]

Despite the path-breaking studies by the Indian medical and scientific community that have contributed to the current diagnostic and therapeutic algorithms, India has the dubious distinction of constituting nearly one-third cases in the world.

To control this expanding problem, the National Tuberculosis Program (NTP) was reviewed by an expert committee appointed by the World Health Organization (WHO) in 1992. Later, to correct the flaws found therein, the Revised National Tuberculosis Control Programme (RNTCP) was formulated and a pilot project was implemented in 1993. [2] It was based on the fact that patients who are sputum smear positive (SSP) are the major source of disease transmission in the community, and therefore a greater emphasis on detecting these cases is given. The primary objectives of the program are to achieve 80% cure rate in new SSP cases and to detect at least 70% of these. The program has laid down criteria for suspicion, disease diagnosis, categorization, treatment, follow-up and outcome of TB patients. A defining feature of the program has been a shift from hospitalized to outpatient management and supervised treatment. All patients under RNTCP receive drugs under direct supervision called Directly Observed Treatment, Short course (DOTS). [2]

In addition to the existing burden of TB, the pandemic of HIV has further aggravated the incidence of TB. HIV infection makes an individual more prone to develop TB and TB is the commonest opportunistic infection amongst HIV-infected individuals, with WHO estimating that 5% of TB patients are also co-infected with HIV. [2] Therefore, proper knowledge of RNTCP is essential not only for TB control but also to contain HIV epidemic.

India has a blend of public and private healthcare delivery systems, with the majority seeking the latter for its perceived confidentiality, convenience of timing, accessibility and personalized management. The private sector is large and mostly unregulated and the care provided has been found to be of inadequate quality. Inappropriate and incomplete prescription and treatment have been identified as major risk factors for the development of the spread of TB and drug resistance. Training of medical students in RNTCP will ensure better future healthcare in the correct diagnosis and treatment of TB. It is against this background that RNTCP has been incorporated as a topic in the undergraduate medical curriculum. Therefore, the present study was conducted to assess awareness of TB, its magnitude, transmission, RNTCP diagnosis, management, risk perception and attitude toward the TB patient.

 Materials and Methods



The study was a cross-sectional survey, carried out in a private medical college, affiliated to the Maharashtra University of Health Sciences, with an annual intake of 100 students. Medical students from third M.B.B.S. - first semester (III/I) and last semester (III/III); and students doing compulsory rotatory internship were asked to complete a written questionnaire comprising 25 questions. A total of 200 students from different batches were administered the questionnaire. The questions were based on their curriculum, published literature including that on the RNTCP published by the Central TB Division, Ministry of Health and Family Welfare, Government of India, which currently forms the core curriculum for undergraduates.

The questionnaire comprised 25 questions, with majority being multiple choice questions (MCQs). The questions were further subdivided into four different categories: Knowledge about disease (3 questions = Q. No. 1-3); epidemiology (4 questions = Q. No. 4-7); diagnosis and management (13 questions = Q. No. 8-19, and 21); attitude and risk perception of TB (5 questions = Q. No. 20 and 22-25).

Prior to administering the questionnaire, the Institutional Review Board and Ethics Committee approval were obtained. The individual questionnaire was submitted to students volunteering to participate after explaining the survey purpose and having their informed consent. The identity of the students was not revealed to maintain confidentiality.

The answers thus recorded were entered into an excel sheet for scoring. Statistical analysis was carried out using SPSS statistical software program. In addition, item analysis was carried out for questions wherever applicable. Item analysis involves the process of evaluating a single MCQ after its MCQ paper correction based on students' response to each MCQ. Various indices are determined such as discriminatory index, difficulty index and distracter effectiveness.

 Results



This study included 200 medical students - 68 interns, 62 III/I semester and 70 III/III semester students. Analysis of data revealed that all the students enrolled were aware of TB, had attended a formal lecture on TB during their academic career, and were also aware of RNTCP. In addition to the didactic lecture, students had gained information from different sources, which are shown in [Table 1].{Table 1}

It was found that the main source of information was mainly didactic lecture (187), followed by textbooks (168), case discussion (155), seminar (95), journals (75), and WHO publications (22). There was an overlap between various responses such as academic activities in class, reading and internet surfing. On the internet, the most common website of information was WHO (33), followed by Center for Disease Control (CDC) (7), especially for the interns.

Among III/III, there were 22 (33.34%) students who scored less than 50%, compared with 6 (9.6%) III/I semester students and 12 (17.65%) interns, which is very high. Hence, such students required a special training for awareness of TB and RNTCP.

Twenty-eight students scored more than 70%, III/I students being maximum in this group - 13 (20.96%), followed by 10 interns (40.70%), and 5 III/III students (7.57%). This high achiever group, after basic training, can volunteer to propagate awareness of the program.

On comparing the percentage of correct responses both in the various question categories and in different student groups, we found that the average number of students who attempted a correct response was 122 (59.63%). Among the various categories of TB, it was found that correct responses were the highest for questions relating to diagnosis 146.25 (73.12%), followed by epidemiology 114 (62.16%), management 130.33 (61.75%), and risk perception 75.33 (28.5%) [Figure 1].{Figure 1}

Group-wise comparison of students for correct response revealed that risk perception awareness of TB was less among all three groups, with the least among the III/I subjects. However, there were more correct respondents among the III/I semester students compared with III/III semester students and interns in areas such as epidemiology, diagnosis and management [Figure 2].{Figure 2}

We also observed that 180 (90%) students feared the risk of transmission by inhalation from TB patients with cough, amongst them 47% completely agreed and 43% partially agreed. There were 20 (10%) students who were unaware of such a risk. About 95% students agreed with the need for personal protective equipment while interviewing and examining patients with TB (79.5% completely agreed and 15.5% partially agreed), whereas 10 (5%) did not agree [Table 2].{Table 2}

Majority (90%) of the students were aware that all smear-positive patients should be isolated and treated. Group-wise distribution of these students showed 56/62 (90.32%) to be in III/I semester, 59/70 (84.28%) in III/III semester, and 65/68 (95.58%) to be interns [Figure 3].{Figure 3}

Students found it difficult to answer questions related to the management and prevention aspect of TB; hence, more emphasis should be given on these aspects of RNTCP while teaching. However, students also felt that the questions related to epidemiology and diagnosis were easy. Following item analysis of the MCQs [Table 3], it was evident how well students have understood RNTCP, which topics need more emphasis, what are the common mistakes and which areas are confusing. The teaching/learning methods can be modified based on these results.{Table 3}

 Discussion



During the analysis on the knowledge about epidemiology, we found that majority of the subjects (63%) were aware about the aims of RNTCP but only 41.5% of students knew that one smear-positive patient could infect 10-15 people. Only 19.35% of students knew that TB is a marker disease for HIV and that alto patients should be screened for HIV and vice versa. These findings are consistent with other similar surveys . Jackson et al. [3] observed deficiencies in the knowledge, attitude, and confidence about TB in students in the medical profession. Moreover, TB patients are socially discriminated, though the level of discrimination is much less compared with leprosy and HIV. A survey of final-year medical students from Canada, India and Uganda by Emili et al. [4] demonstrated significant differences in undergraduate exposure to TB, total knowledge, and practice competency at three medical schools in Canada, India and Uganda.

Survey on the diagnostic and management aspect showed that most (92%) of the students knew that cough is the commonest symptom of TB and sputum microscopy is the most specific test for diagnosing infection. However, very few knew that one requires minimum 5% sodium hypochlorite to kill Mycobacterium tuberculosis bacilli. Majority of students knew about DOTS but only 20.5% of students knew how to manage a smear-negative TB patient. Most of the students were not updated about the dosage of anti-tuberculous drugs. Only 30.5% mentioned the correct dose of INH.

Various studies have shown that the knowledge of diagnosis and treatment of TB has lacunae. In an article [5] from New Delhi TB center, 141 different treatment regimens were mentioned in the responses and of them only 11 (7.8%) were therapeutically rational. A survey conducted of 460 interns from five Pakistani teaching hospitals showed only 22% correctly identified the estimated number of new TB cases in Pakistan. [6] Only 38% considered sputum smears for acid fast bacilli as the optimal test for diagnosis of pulmonary TB and 43.5% for follow-up during TB treatment. Most interns (82%) were unable to identify a single component of the DOTS strategy. The study reflected poor awareness of and low compliance to the WHO/NTP guidelines amongst interns. In 2005, Jackson et al. [3] found that one-third medical students did not know the method of administering tuberculin, or that Bacillus Calmette Guerin (BCG) vaccine was not a contraindication for the tuberculin skin test.

Our analysis on the risk perception and attitude toward TB patients revealed surprising results. Only 17% of students knew intubation has one of highest risks of transmission and that the N95 respiratory mask provides protection against TB (6%). Responses of various students among different categories reveal that risk perception awareness was less among all the three groups; however, compared with the 3 rd year students, the interns had a marginally better risk perception. The reason could be that the interns do much more of clinical and practical work compared with students. Rao et al. [7] reported an overall risk of 11.2 cases per 1000 interns working in Post Graduate Institute, Chandigarh. The risk was higher (17.3 cases per 1000) in the interns within 1 st year of joining the hospital, hence reinforcing the need to implement simple, effective, and affordable TB infection control measures in healthcare facilities.

Item analysis of the MCQs revealed that the level of difficulty for most of the items/questions was higher in III/I semester students compared with III/III semester students and interns. This indicates that for the III/I semester students, the exam was easier and that they have better knowledge about RNTCP than the III/III semester students and interns. The reason could be related to recently acquired knowledge, as III/I semester students have fresh knowledge about the subject. However, for interns, the difficulty index for most of the questions was very low, indicating the interns felt the questions were difficult; this could be because recall of past memory is poor, busy schedule of interns and the stress of preparation of entrance exams for post-graduation. Topic-wise comparison of the difficulty index revealed that all three groups had less knowledge of risk perception of TB. This might explain the increasing trend of TB infection among the medical personnel, thereby emphasizing the importance of universal safety precautions and personal protective equipment.

 Conclusions



All students were aware of RNTCP. The overall performance of III/I students was better than the rest of the study group. Students performed better in the epidemiology domain as compared to the management and preventive aspects of TB, emphasizing the fact that these aspects of TB should be considered. The average correct response in the different groups ranged from 28% to 62%, which is far from acceptable, as TB is a serious public health concern in India.

Training should be imparted to the students covering all aspects of TB by conducting continuous medical education programs every year. In Second MBBS, a course on pathogenesis and diagnosis of TB, including RNTCP; in Third MBBS on the DOTS and DOTS + strategies; and also an orientation course at the beginning of internship will definitely help the students to improve their knowledge on TB. Therefore, we recommend that to ensure the successful control of TB and successful implementation of RNTCP, we need to sensitize medical students and future healthcare providers on a regular basis.

Extremely drug resistant (XDR) TB has been reported from Mumbai in 2012. Moreover, multidrug resistant (MDR) TB has become a burning problem today. Therefore, new researches should be started on XDR TB along with intensification of research activities on MDR TB.

 Acknowledgment



The study was conducted as an ICMR short-term research studentship project (STS), 2008. No. 21/556/08 - BMS.

References

1Rothschild BM, Martin LD, Lev G, Bercovier H, Bar-Gal GK, Greenblatt C, et al. Mycobacterium tuberculosis complex DNA from an extinct bison dated 17,000 years before the present. Clin Infect Dis 2001;33:305-11.
2Central TB Division, Directorate General of Health Services, Ministry of Health and Family Welfare. Managing the Revised National Tuberculosis Control Programme in your area. A training course. Modules 1-4 and 5-9. April 2005; p. 1-182 and 1-248.
3Jackson M, Harrity S, Hoffman H, Catanzaro A. A survey of health professions students for knowledge, attitudes, and confidence about tuberculosis, 2005. BMC Public Health 2007;7:219. Available at: http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-2458/7/219. [Last accessed November 2010].
4Emili J, Scott F, Upshur RE, Schmuck ML, John KR. Attitudes toward tuberculosis of final year medical students from Canada, India, and Uganda. Teach Learn Med 2002;14:168-74.
5Rajpal S, Mittal A, Dhingra VK, Malhotra R, Gupta R, Malhotra C, et al. Knowledge, attitude and practices regarding tuberculosis and DOTS among interns in Delhi, India. J Coll Physicians Surg Pak 2007;17:457-61.
6Khan JA, Zahid S, Khan R, Hussain SF, Rizvi N, Rab A, et al. Medical interns knowledge of TB in Pakistan. Trop Doct 2005;35:144-7.
7Rao KG, Aggarwal AN, Behera D. Tuberculosis among physicians in training. Int J Tuberc Lung Dis 2004;8:1392-4.